Go to fullsize image

Apparently I am a neo-Luddite.


I discovered this after reading an interesting article by Lowell Monke in Orion Magazine the other day. In the article, “Unplugged Schools” Monke suggests the need to ensure that we don’t substitute technology for personal interaction in the classroom. Since schools are one of the main institutions that influence a child’s social development it seems clear to me that they have a responsibility to provide a balanced curriculum which allows time for real experiences and social skill building.


Monke said “Compensation for an overheated technological culture should not be mistaken for rejection of it.” Even so, a couple of readers jumped on him for being a neo-Luddite, ignoring the bit about Monke being a technology teacher for the past 15 years.


The Luddite movement which began in the early 1800’s was a response to industrialization in the textile industry. I imagine them meeting secretly in dark barns, plotting the destruction of looms and knitting machines between swigs of strong ale. Luddism wasn’t fueled by fear but by pure economics. People were losing their livelihood to machines which couldn’t produce the quality of craftsmanship that the artisans could.


The label “Luddite” is now commonly used by people who neither understand the history behind the movement nor identify with those of us who do attempt a conscious approach to living. It’s just another derogatory label used by pseudointellectuals. (The irony here was intentional.) 


“Life without industry is guilt, and industry without art is brutality.” John Ruskin


One Response to “Neo-luddite”

  1. secretinsidegirl Says:

    You’re right on with this one. I keep getting pushed to use PowerPoint in the classroom, but what I’ve noticed is students check out as soon as the screen goes down and the presentation’s “lesson” begins. They treat it as passively as television. Invariably, my best classes — the ones where students leave having actually learned something that they then retain — are a mixture of lecture, questioning, discussion, and application. No PowerPoints in sight. Nothing more technologically advanced than a chalkboard.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: